John Coltrane. Pic: Hugo van Gelderen
Blame the iPod. The ubiquity of that little device in the mid-2000s changed the working lives of many of my generation.
That, and the noisy open-plan offices we worked in. Steve Jobs’ little white box provided a perfect way to drown out background noise, focus on the task at hand, increase focus and productivity.
Perhaps it did, for some. As a working journalist in those years, listening to music wasn’t an option. The time you spent after phoning and meeting contacts was used to write, usually against a deadline. Fidgeting for the new Coldplay song five minutes before your copy was due was not advisable.
Outside the office it was different matter. At home I’d write and read to a constant soundtrack, and still do. Over the years I found some recordings worked better than others when it came to cognitive function.
For months I read at night to Aphex Twin’s “Selected Ambient Works Volume II”. But when I tried to do the same with John Coltrane’s “A Love Supreme” it was a no-go. I’d barely last five minutes. Beethoven’s sonatas? No problem. Bob Dylan? Not a chance.
After years of hit-and-miss listening I recently investigated what works and what doesn’t.
With the help of a couple of articles, from Inc and Time, I’ve narrowed it down – for myself at least.
Here’s the secret:
- Listen to music without lyrics (no Dylan, more Beethoven)
- Don’t listen to new music
- Don’t listen if you’re trying to learn something new (the line between this and reading for pleasure is blurred, I find)
- If you’re learning something new, listen before you start
- If the task at hand is repetitive, listen to music (even if you’re a surgeon)
- If there’s a lot of background noise, music you’re familiar with will calm your brain, improving focus
A case in point: as I write this I am listening to Caribou’s album Swim. It’s a recording I know pretty well, with songs whose lyrics are simple, few and repetitive. Hearing the music raises my levels of feel-good neurotransmitters (dopamine and serotonin), which relaxes me and helps me focus. My thought process is smooth and my output is consistent.
As a test I’ve now switched it out for one of my favorite non-cognitive tracks, music I use during workouts but not elsewhere – Slayer’s Raining Blood. My foot’s tapping but my concentration’s shot.
My perfect music while working is somewhere between these two poles – Brian Eno’s Discreet Music or Dustin O’Halloran’s Lumiere are two albums that spring to mind.
Of course there’s a simpler way to improve your working focus, your reading and your writing: work in complete silence and listen to nothing. Modern life renders the first impossible and, frankly, where’s the fun in the second?